Selection and estimation for mixed graphical models. A graphical model represents variables as nodes and uses edges between nodes so that separations re. Complex computations which are required to perform inference and learning in sophisticated models can be expressed in terms of graphical manip. Aug 24, 2012 click on the title to browse this issue. A complete subgraph is a subgraph which is complete.
The relationship between collapsibility and confounding has been subject to an extensive and ongoing discussion in the methodological literature. The hypergraph language, which is currently used to specify the syntax of elms, both provides an insight into key notions of the theory of elms such as collapsibility and decomposability, and allows to work out efficient algorithms to solve some problems of inference. Model building for logit and loglinear models edpspsych. On the collapsibility of measures of effect in the. Undirected graphical models, also known as markov networks or markov random elds mrfs, are more popular with the physics and vision communities. The property of collapsibility, in this context, means that the multivariate cgregression can be decomposed into lower dimensional regressions that are still cg and are consistent with the corresponding.
More recently, evans 2015 demonstrated smoothness of certain mll parameterizations. An introduction to graphical models ubc computer science. In this article, we introduce a new class of graphical loglinear models, called qs graphical models, in which certain interaction parameters are restricted to be identical for sets of variables. However, one nice feature of graphical models is that they lead to simplifying loglinear models. Blei columbia university october 3, 2015 introduction these notes follow chapter 2 of an introduction to probabilistic graphical models by. Graphical models in applied multivariate statistics. Causal diagrams and the identification of causal effects 4. The denominator is known as the partition function and it comprises the sum over all ql possible labelling of y to ensure that pynxn,w adds up to one. They are decomposable models collapsible models decomposable models are graphical models for which closedform mles exist. Adjustments and their consequencescollapsibility analysis using. Collapsibility of marginal models for categorical data.
In this article, we introduce a new class of graphical loglinear models, called qs graphical models, in which certain interaction parameters are. Collapsibility of some association measures and survival models. Special attention is given to definitions of confounding, problems in control of confounding, the relation of confounding to exchangeability and collapsibility, and the importance of distinguishing confounding from noncollapsibility. Consequently, results from greenland and pearl do not apply under definition 2, and measures of effect may be collapsible over \v\ even if \v\ is a. We propose a new class of semiparametric exponential family graphical models for the analysis of high dimensional mixed data. Keywords collapsibility conditional independence contingency table. Gaussian graphical models, namely, weakly kseparable and strongly kseparable gaus. Request pdf collapsibility of contingency tables based on conditional models strict collapsibility and model collapsibility are two important concepts. Gaussian graphical models, namely, weakly kseparable and strongly k separable gaus. On marginal and conditional parameters in logistic regression. Probabilistic graphical models are a powerful, elegant and simple way to specify such a family. Collapsibility of graphical cgregression models core. Elements of graphical models department of statistics. Graphical models for inference under outcomedependent sampling.
In figure 1 the graph on the right has cliques b1,c,b1,x, x,y and b2,c,y. We consider situations where data have been collected such that the sampling depends on the outcome of interest and possibly further covariates, as for instance in casecontrol studies. Collapsibility of conditional graphical models in this paper, we consider two kinds of collapsibility, that is, the model. Collapsibility in recursive graphical models 3 a graphical model is a statistical model whose model structure can be represented by a graph, and we will denote the graph of a graphical model by g v.
Overivew graphicalmodels collapsibility modelingordinal ordinal vsindependence conditional independence sparsedata incomplete usefulness of graphical models graphical models are useful and are widely applicable because 1. Graphical models provide additional insights into the properties of the model, including the conditional independence properties. The basics of graphical models columbia university. The above conditional independence restrictions that are induced by an undirected graph go hand in hand with a fac torization of the joint distribution in terms of these cliques. The absence of a common ancestor, in turn, implies the satisfaction of either u whenever or u z z satis. Simpsons paradox, confounding, and collapsibility 7. E, where v is the index set of the nodes involved in the model and e a set of edges between the nodes in v.
We here provide an overview of confounding and related concepts based on a counterfactual model for causation. Collapsibility of conditional graphical models binghui liu key laboratory for applied statistics of moe and school of mathematics and statistics, northeast normal university and. Graphical and recursive models for contingency tables math. Correspondence analysis and association models constrained. Studying noncollapsibility of the odds ratio with marginal.
Following the theoremproofremarks format, this introduction to the use of graphical models in the description and modeling of multivariate systems covers conditional independence, several types of independence graphs, gaussian models, issues in model selection, regression and decomposition. Collapsibility of conditional graphical models request pdf. Bayesian graphical models for multivariate functional data. Collapsibility for directed acyclic graphs request pdf. An algebraic and geometric perspective caroline uhler abstract gaussian graphical models are used throughout the natural sciences, social sciences, and economics to model the statistical relationships between variables of interest in the form of a graph. Di erent from the existing mixed graphical models, we allow the nodewise conditional distributions to be semiparametric generalized linear models. Learning structured output representation using deep conditional generative models kihyuk sohn yxinchen yan honglak lee nec laboratories america, inc. In this paper, we consider two kinds of collapsibility, that is, the model collapsibility and the estimate collapsibility, of conditional graphical models for multidimensional contingency tables. The notion of conditional independence is fundamental for graphical models. Collapsibility deals with the conditions under which a conditional on a covariate w measure of association between two random variables y and x equals the marginal measure of association. Studying noncollapsibility of the authors 20 the odds. Collapsibility of contingency tables based on conditional models article in journal of statistical planning and inference 1405.
Collapsibility of conditional graphical models, scandinavian. Conditional graphical models for protein structure prediction. One approach to quantifying the magnitude of confounding in observational studies is to compare estimates with and without adjustment for a covariate, but this strategy is known to be defective for noncollapsible measures such as the odds ratio. Collapsibility of marginal models for categorical data deepai. Graphical models have enjoyed a surge of interest in the last two decades, due both to the. Jun 01, 20 collapsibility of conditional graphical models collapsibility of conditional graphical models liu, binghui. Graphical models for inference under outcomedependent. Learning unfaithful kseparable gaussian graphical models. Decomposabe models one nice feature of graphical models is that they lead immediately to two important ideas in simplifying loglinear models. Jensen f 2002 hugin api reference manual version 5. Collapsibility is closely related to the nonoccurrence of simpsons. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda.
In this paper, we obtain several results related to collapsibility and strict collapsibility of the more general mll parameters for modelling categorical data. In this paper, we discuss the average collapsibility of certain wellknown measures of association, and also with respect to a new measure of association. We here provide a pedagogic introduction to gaussian graphical. Collapsibility of conditional graphical models liu 20. A hypergraphtheoretic analysis of collapsibility and. An introduction to categorical data analysis second edition alan agresti. Marginalisation and collapsibility in graphical interaction models. In this paper, we obtain some necessary and sufficient conditions for the strict collapsibility of the full model, with respect to an interaction factor or a set of interaction factors, based on the interaction parameters of the conditional layer loglinear models. Model building for logit and loglinear models edps. Graphical models for machine learning and digital communication, brendan j. Vijay some collapsibility results for ndimensional. A graph allows us to abstract out the conditional independence relationships between the variables from the details of their parametric forms.
Loglinear models are a special case of undirected graphical models, and are popular in statistics. This survey aims at making these advances more accessible to the general research community by. Introduction to graphical modelling 3 in markov networks graphical separation which is called undirected separation or useparationin castillo et al. In this thesis, a framework of conditional graphical models is developed to predict protein structures. Collapsibility of conditional graphical models liu. The property of collapsibility, in this context, means that the multivariate cg. Directed graphical models, also known as bayesian networks bns, belief networks, generative. Graphical models for inference under outcomedependent sampling vanessa didelez, svend kreiner and niels keiding abstract. Collapsibility of contingency tables based on conditional models. Symbiosis between counterfactual and graphical methods. A graph is said to be complete if all vertices are adjacent to each other. Graphical models represent assumptions about the conditional independencies among the variables.
In this paper, we study mixed graphical models under a much more general setting, in which the conditional distributions of the nodes belong to the exponential family. Graphical models express conditional independence relationships among variables. Their recommendation is based on the fact that collapsibility holds under either or both of two conditional independencies as well as under other conditions. Collapsibility of contingency tables based on conditional. Adjustments and their consequencescollapsibility analysis. Basic to our representation is the notion of conditional independence.
We also study the theoretical properties of penalized. In this paper we introduce a sparse conditional gaussian graphical model for studying the conditional independent relationships among a set of gene expressions adjusting for possible genetic effects where the gene expressions are modeled with seemingly unrelated regressions. Collapsibility of graphical cgregression models request pdf. Decomposable models have nice collapsibility features. Introduction to probabilities, graphs, and causal models 2. In this paper, we consider two kinds of collapsibility, that is, the model. Graphical models in applied multivariate statistics joe. Collapsibility of parameter estimates for undirected graphical models over some variables has been discussed in 9,151617, and that of dags has been discussed in 18, 19. Parametric collapsibility implies that the adcparameters are constant across different levels of b and c not only in the complete model, but also in the marginal model. On semiparametric exponential family graphical models. Extended loglinear models elms are the natural generalization of loglinear models when the positivity assumption is relaxed. The subset of distributions that respect all the ci assumptions we make is the family of distributions consisitent with our assumptions. Rcassociation model collapsibility conditional independence correspondence analysis graphical model independence graph loglinear model multiway contingency table score additivity thanks are due to anonymous referees who substantially improved the original draft of this paper.
Collapsibility of conditional graphical models binghui liu key laboratory for applied statistics of moe and school of mathematics and statistics, northeast normal university and school of mathematics, jilin university. Gaussian graphical models gaussian graphical models ste en lauritzen university of oxford cimpa summerschool, hammamet 2011, tunisia september 8, 2011 ste en lauritzen university of oxford gaussian graphical models. Causality and structural models in the social sciences 6. Causal inference, collapsibility, odds ratios, selection bias. Adjustments and their consequences collapsibility analysis. A note on collapsibility in recursive graphical models of. We consider probabilistic and graphical rules for detecting situations in which a dependence of one variable on another is altered by adjusting for a third variable i. Cgregressions are multivariate regression models for mixed continuous and discrete responses that result from conditioning in the class of conditional gaussian cg models. This definition includes pure conditioning, in which the summary is the list vector of cconditional dependence measures, such as cspecific risk differences, risk ratios, log odds ratios, and so on. Collapsibility can then be understood as a mathematical property of the effect measure, rather than a consequence of certain graphical or probabilistic structures in the particular data set. This is a consequence of the dseparation rule section 1. Used for identifying direct associations and indirect associations among random variables.
We discuss two subtly different definitions of collapsibility, and show that by considering causal effect measures based on counterfactual variables rather than measures of association based on observed variables it is possible to separate out the. It also plays an important role for proving the hammersleyclifford theorem see lauritzen 1996, p. We investigate the compatibility of such models when assuming pairwise interactions. In this paper, we discuss local structure recovery for a cg when there exist unobserved or latent variables or after marginalization over observed variables. Decomposable models are graphical models for which closed form mles exist, and they correspond to decomposable loglinear models.
1339 200 463 1209 1248 850 594 1032 199 1125 1188 940 1429 1047 849 198 412 753 226 1497 1415 980 453 56 1410 1247 763 243 963 215 1325 1370 753 1035 1163 368 1464 236 898 1260 1111 1017 1473 1116 1037